Which Claw is the best for office use? A comparison of 5 intelligent agents tested.
This year's shrimp war is even more spectacular than when DeepSeek was integrated! Major companies have invested heavily in office environments, launching their own OpenClaw lobsters, sparking a nationwide shrimp-raising craze.
This year's shrimp war is even more spectacular than when DeepSeek was integrated! Major companies have invested heavily in office environments, launching their own OpenClaw lobsters, sparking a nationwide shrimp-raising craze.
Despite the hype, many people are probably still a bit confused: what exactly can a lobster do? With major companies releasing their own versions, how do I choose the best one?
To understand these issues, I spent three days conducting in-depth evaluations of five mainstream lobster varieties in real-world work settings.The three internet giants, Baidu (DuMate), Alibaba (JVS Claw), and Tencent (QClaw), and AI Large ModelListed companies AutoClaw and MiniMax MaxClaw.
Next, I will give you a comprehensive understanding of these lobsters from the aspects of installation and configuration, real office experience, cost and security.
Before we begin the comparison, let's first...SimpleLet's learn about these five lobsters:
Baidu DuMate
Backed by Baidu, it is the first fully-fledged enterprise-grade version of OpenClaw in China. With its strong Chinese search engine capabilities and the support of the Baidu ecosystem, it integrates various applications and file formats (documents, spreadsheets, emails, web pages) in office scenarios, enabling cross-application operation and...automaticEnhance task execution capabilities.
Alibaba JVS Claw
Alibaba Cloud launched multiple Agent intelligentbodyThis collaboration platform, built upon Alibaba's e-commerce and enterprise collaboration (DingTalk) DNA, emphasizes understanding processes and getting things done. It can command multiple expert-level personnel with a single command. Agent Collaborative work, with an independent cloud environment, physically isolated from private data.
Tencent QClaw
Tencent PC Manager team built a local application based on OpenClaw. AI Assistant, with built-in Kimi-K2.5 and other domestic productsLarge ModelIt supports direct connection to WeChat.
Zhipu AutoClaw
The local version of OpenClaw integrates the GLM-5-Turbo lobster-specific model and AutoGLM-Browser.Agent Browser operation capabilities, ability to execute complex multi-step tasks, logical reasoning ability, and coding ability are among the best in China.Large ModelIt has consistently ranked among the top in the country.
MiniMax MaxClaw
MiniMax's general-purpose processor is designed for handling long-term, complex tasks.intelligentbodyIt is supported by a Multi-agent System. It allows for deep manipulation of desktop applications.automaticProcess local files and web pages, transforming complex industry experience into a dedicated expert assistant.
For ordinary workers, the installation barrier is a decisive factor. If the tools are too difficult to install, it will deter them from even trying.
Installation and Configuration
DuMate, AutoClaw, and QClaw are all lightweight installation packages; simply double-click to run and they're ready to use right out of the box—a truly seamless experience..
MaxClaw uses a web-based interface.One-clickdeployIt can be turned on and used in about 10 seconds, and it's also very...Simple.
JVS Claw can also be used by opening a web browser.Furthermore, you can customize the lobster's style and skills right from the initial interface.
Integrate with Lark and other IM services
As an office worker, integrating lobster into the company's commonly used communication software is a necessity. I tested it using Lark as an example:
AutoClaw automatically sets up IM channels, allowing instant connection to WeChat, Lark, and Enterprise WeChat by scanning a QR code. (Only QQ requires manual configuration).
MaxClaw simply sends the message "Connect to Lark," and it will return a link to create an OpenClaw Lark robot. Click "Create Now" to connect instantly.
DuMate, JVS Claw, and QClaw require you to manually retrieve the Lark app's App ID and App Secret before you can bind them.
Overall, the difficulty of deploying and integrating Lark is not significantly different. AutoClaw and MaxClaw have slightly simpler steps..
Without further ado, let's get straight to testing real-world work examples.
Build a video inspiration pipeline. When I chat with you using the format "This is a content creation inspiration 'xxx'", I will search the entire internet and research the popularity of related discussions on Douyin and Xiaohongshu.PopularConsider the angle, common viewpoints, the questions readers care about most, and whether similar content has become homogenized. Generate a complete article plan: suggested titles, article angle, opening hook, body structure framework, core viewpoints that can be developed in each section, and, considering current trends, competition, room for content differentiation, and dissemination potential, make a clear judgment on whether this topic is worth writing about. Finally, put the compiled results into a Word file.
DuMate understood the overall requirements in 30 seconds and outlined a clear workflow..
We input a creative idea:
This is a content creation inspiration from the "Baidu Tieba (Baixia Bar)".
DuMate completed the process in just 8 minutes, and the generated document quality was very high..
The content is comprehensive, including trend analysis, user opinion analysis, and content differentiation analysis. It also provides the title, insertion point, body framework, and core viewpoints for each section. Finally, it accurately judges the content as "extremely popular, highly timely, and with room for differentiation."
The layout is pleasing to the eye, the content is clear, and different font sizes and colors are used to highlight key points.The most readable and highest quality deliverable across all tests.
AutoClaw and MaxClaw are very thoughtful; they not only created the workflow but also proactively ran a test of the case studies.
AutoClaw generated the document in 5 minutes, and even analyzed the timeliness, research costs and other risks of this topic. The article structure was very complete.
MaxClaw's value judgments were accurate, but the generated document was initially corrupted and only became barely readable after repair.
The fixed version is here:
At first glance, it's densely packed with text, making it less readable. I feel more stressed than browsing trending topics on my own.
JVS Claw offers two solutions:
The generated document is decent in terms of content direction, but the content is relatively concise.
QClaw was interrupted the first time:
After another attempt, the design proposal was actually quite appealing, offering several versions and distribution suggestions, but its stability was a drawback.
Try cross-application again.automaticHow did the lobsters perform under the chemical treatment?
Download last30days-skill from GitHub and put it on my desktop.
Because I forgot to turn on my international Wi-Fi, DuMate kept showing network connection problems. While I was trying to find other solutions, it finally downloaded the app successfully via a mirror source. The whole process took less than 3 minutes..
Their problem-solving skills are quite good.
AutoClaw encountered the same problem, but attempts to mirror the image were unsuccessful.
After adjusting the network settings, it worked on the first try!
Both MaxClaw and JVS Claw are cloud-based lobsters and cannot directly interact with local files.
JVS Claw could not find a GitHub repository address, butI successfully found the skill using find-skills, but I need to install it manually following the prompts..
MaxClaw prepares the files in the cloud, and we just need to click to download them manually, which is very convenient.Simple.
QClaw was quite annoyed; the first attempt was inexplicably interrupted again.
The second attempt prompted me with several Invoke-WebRequest permission requests, but it still ended in failure.
Besides usability and portability, our biggest concern is how expensive it is to raise lobsters. Let's compare the points/token consumption in this test:
DuMate: King of Value for Money
Currently inLimited Time OfferfreeDuring this phase, new users will receive 1000 points daily (refreshed at 00:00 every day). This task only used a mere 16 points, which is a godsend for free-to-play users. Even if the subsequent preferential policies change, this amount of points is still very substantial.
Beginner-friendly: JVS Claw
New users 7 days without deducting pointsThis test consumed 104 points, with an actual cost of 0 yuan. For long-term use, the entry-level monthly plan is offered at a limited-time discount of 39 yuan/month, including 1600 points, with 20 points awarded daily.
MiniMax
The entry-level monthly plan is on sale for a limited time at 39 yuan/month, including 5000 points, with 200 points awarded for logging in daily. This task consumes 55 points. Long-term users can also choose to integrate with the MiniMax Coding Plan.
AutoClaw
New users receive 320 points. This task consumed 1672 points, equivalent to 9.7 yuan based on the introductory package. Any API can be accessed.Large Model.
"The Great Injustice": QClaw
This is really outrageous! Not only was the task success rate low, but the second task failed, and the system deducted a total of 2.913 million tokens from my account. Although QClaw generously gave new users 40 million tokens, this deduction is incredibly fast.
When entrusting work data to lobsters, safety is absolutely paramount.
in this regard,Large companies inspire more confidence. Alibaba's JVS Claw provides each user with an independent cloud environment.Users experience direct physical data isolation. Furthermore, the entire communication and storage environment employs end-to-end encryption, with cloud storage volumes encrypted by default, adhering to financial-grade data security standards.
MiniMax runs on MiniMax cloud servers, physically isolated from the user's local device.User data is stored in the cloud, even AI Even if it gets out of control, it won't directly threaten local computer files.
AutoClaw user data is stored in the local workspace by default, and is restricted by a sandbox. AI Accessible file system range,when AI Manual confirmation is required before performing high-risk operations.
DuMate achieves isolation from the native device environment by pre-installing a security sandbox.The code, tasks, and files are all executed within a closed loop, without affecting the local environment, spreading risks, or leaking core data.
For high-risk operations such as file deletion, system modification, and data sharing, DuMate will force users to give explicit authorization before execution.The powerful combination of local data processing and cloud encryption ensures information security for both users and enterprises..
After comparing and evaluating these five types of lobsters from so many dimensions, I believe everyone now has a clearer understanding of their characteristics.
Pursuing both high-quality content and an all-around user experiencerecommendBaidu DuMate is the first choice..
Whether it's planning complex long articles or cross-application projects...automaticWhether it's a network outage or an error message, it's a process of deactivation.intelligentDuMate's performance in processing is impressive. Currently offered for a limited-time free trial, and featuring an enterprise-level security sandbox mechanism, it's the top choice for both quality and value.
Strong code logic and process planning are required.recommendZhipu AutoClawIts content generation quality is second only to DuMate, its IM integration is very smooth, and its data localization and isolation are well done, making it suitable for developers.
For light office work, choose MiniMax MaxClaw or Alibaba JVS Claw.Both of these are cloud-based and do not consume local memory, allowing you to raise shrimp without a computer.
Lobsters still occasionally make silly mistakes, but they've demonstrated terrifying productivity when handling standardized, tedious office workflows. A good, handy lobster can truly double our work efficiency, allowing us to leave work earlier!
Original link:A comparative review of 5 major domestic lobster brands – surprisingly, this is the best one!